What is the Best Buffalo Jerky to Buy Online?

What is the Best Buffalo Jerky to Buy Online?

You're here because you have an appetite for something unique, something bold, something satisfyingly delicious. You’re looking for the best bison jerky - and you’ve come to the right place. 

If you're already a jerky aficionado, you understand the thrilling chew, the satisfying texture, and the delightful burst of flavors that jerky offers. But bison jerky? It's a game-changer from both a taste and nutrition standpoint.

But, what is the best buffalo jerky to buy online? We’re here to save you from the frustration, disappointment, and stress that come with finding the right jerky brand. Below, we’ll explain what separates the best from the rest when it comes to buffalo jerky to help you feel more confident as you start shopping.

However, we won’t leave you stranded to search for the best tasting buffalo jerky online. We’ll point you in the right direction. The truth is, you don’t need to go far. Our buffalo jerky for sale is second to none. 

Through our strict sourcing, unique mahogany wood smoking process, and meticulous dehydrating & seasoning techniques, we’ve developed the best online jerky selection. 

But, before we talk more about what makes our premium jerky so special, we want to set the stage by talking about what makes buffalo jerky itself a worthy addition to your pantry.

Why You Need to Try the Best Bison Jerky 

The art of jerky making is an age-old tradition, passed down through generations, transformed, and perfected over centuries. When it comes to bison jerky, this delicious and nutritious snack transcends its humble origins and takes a leap into the extraordinary. That’s why it’s our favorite alternative to beef jerky

Bison jerky holds a unique place in the world of jerky for good reason. Unlike traditional beef jerky taste, bison jerky brings a distinctive taste to your palate - slightly sweet, somewhat nutty, and deeply satisfying. It offers a robust, full-bodied flavor that is simultaneously lean and rich. The texture is as enticing as the flavor, providing a rewarding chew that's neither too tough nor too soft. 

Yet, it is not just about a tantalizing buffalo jerky taste and texture. It's a powerhouse of nutrition as well. In fact, it’s considered among the healthiest jerky types out there even compared to high-protein beef jerky or turkey jerky for weight loss.

Packed with high-quality protein, it's an excellent source of fuel for your body. It provides important nutrients like iron, zinc, and B vitamins, and impressively, it does so with fewer calories and less fat than beef. This perfect blend of taste and nutrition makes bison jerky an indulgence you can feel good about.

However, as with all the different types of jerky, you need to be careful in selecting the specific brands and products you try - unless you’re crafting your own buffalo jerky recipe, of course. The last thing you want is to eagerly tear open that package only to be underwhelmed by taste or texture. Or worse - take a second look at the ingredients label to uncover questionable additives. 

That being said, how can you make sure you’re truly getting the best bison jerky? There are a few things you can look at when shopping to feel more confident and secure in making your purchase.

What Separates the Best Buffalo Jerky From the Rest?

When it comes to finding the best buffalo jerky, it's not just about taste - there's a whole lot more that goes into a top-tier snack. From sourcing to preparation, every step of the process can have a huge impact on the final product. Let's dig into what sets the best bison jerky apart from the rest.

The Importance of High-Quality Ingredients

Just as with the best cut of beef for jerky, high-quality buffalo jerky starts with premium-grade bison meat. It should ideally be sourced from animals raised without hormones or antibiotics. 

The meat should be lean and trimmed of fat to ensure a superior texture and taste. High-quality jerky also steers clear of artificial preservatives, MSG, and excessive salt, relying instead on natural ingredients for flavor and preservation. 

When choosing buffalo jerky, look for brands that list ingredients you can recognize and pronounce. This is generally a good rule of thumb for weeding out sketchy ingredients that don’t belong in your diet.

How the Preparation Process Influences the Taste and Texture

The way buffalo jerky is prepared greatly impacts its final taste and texture. Quality brands will marinate the bison meat for an optimal period, allowing the flavors to deeply penetrate the meat. 

The best jerky is slow-smoked, a process that not only imbues it with a smoky, savory flavor, but also dehydrates the meat just enough to preserve it while maintaining its natural tenderness. 

You’d easily be able to tell the difference between a brand that puts this level of detail and commitment into its jerky smoking process and a brand that is chasing a quick buck. 

Fortunately, you won’t have to suffer through overdried or poorly marinated jerky experience. By getting the best bison jerky through our recommendation in the next section, you can rest assured you’re getting the quality you deserve. But what about sustainability and ethics?

The Role of Ethical Sourcing and Sustainability

Consumers are becoming conscious of the sourcing of their food now more than ever. Ethically sourced buffalo jerky comes from bison that have been raised humanely, often free-ranging, which not only is better for the animal but also results in healthier and more flavorful meat. 

Additionally, sustainability practices in the packaging and production processes are increasingly important. The best buffalo jerky brands are those that align with these values.

Always Look at a Brand’s Reputation

The reputation of a brand can tell you a lot about the quality of their buffalo jerky. Look for brands that are transparent about their sourcing, ingredients, and production methods. 

Check out customer reviews and ratings to get a sense of what real people think about the product. A consistently high-rated brand is usually a safe bet for high-quality buffalo jerky. But, don’t just read reviews on the company’s website, as these are chosen meticulously and can often be doctored. See what sort of independent, unbiased testimonials you can dig up.


By considering these factors, you'll be better equipped to distinguish between ordinary and top-tier buffalo jerky. The best jerky doesn't cut corners - it's a product of quality ingredients, careful preparation, ethical sourcing, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. 

All that being said, what is the best buffalo jerky to buy online? Below, we'll reveal the best bison jerky that checks all these boxes.

So, What is the Best Buffalo Jerky to Buy Online?

Look no further, your search for the ultimate buffalo jerky ends here! If you crave superior quality, outstanding flavors, and a jerky experience that goes above and beyond, Mahogany Smoked Meats is the undisputed choice. But why exactly do jerky aficionados around the country prefer our jerky snacks?

What Makes Mahogany Smoked Meats the #1 Choice for Buffalo Jerky Online?

What sets Mahogany Smoked Meats apart is our unwavering commitment to excellence at every stage of the process. We've been doing things the old-fashioned way for more than a century now - using a deep log-pit smoking method, and hand-slicing our meats

By creating our smoked meats in small batches, we’re able to maintain the highest standards for quality and practice meticulous attention to detail. We make sure our buffalo jerky is smoked long and deep with mahogany logs, a detail that results in a rich, unique gourmet flavor.

Why mahogany? Mahogany, unlike the usual hickory, imparts a unique aroma and taste that's incredibly tantalizing, giving our jerky an edge over others. Plus, we only use mahogany logs that have naturally fallen - another reflection of our commitment to environmental sustainability.

And, while you came here searching for the best bison jerky, that’s just the tip of the iceberg in our online storefront. We’re also proud to offer beef jerky for sale, elk jerky for sale, wild boar jerky for sale, and fish jerky for sale.

Across our full catalog, we’ve earned a reputation as the best jerky maker online. And, you don’t just have to take our word for it - see what our customers had to say after trying our snacks themselves…

Don’t Just Take Our Word For it…

“Literally the best jerky I have ever had! All of their jerky & other products are the BOMB 🔥🔥💣💣” - Drew

“Outstanding big game jerky. I will always buy from this company!” - Jeffrey

“Definitely one of the best jerkies I have ever had. The flavor and thickness of this jerky is outstanding. I received a sample pack and will definitely buy in the future.” - Rodolfo

“I've purchased from them 4 years. They're great!” - Patricia

“My go-to meat along with the elk. Love the moisture and flavor.” - Nathan

Our Best Tasting Buffalo Jerky Varieties

We take pride in our array of flavor profiles, each designed to tickle your taste buds in a unique way. Let's introduce you to some of our best buffalo jerky varieties:

  • Black Peppered Buffalo Jerky: This lean buffalo jerky is made from our classic Western Beef Jerky recipe of soy sauce, wine, garlic, and pepper. It's the leanest jerky we offer, making it the perfect snack for those looking to watch their waistline or refuel after a workout.
  • Teriyaki Buffalo Jerky: This sweet and tangy option is crafted in small batches to ensure every bite is packed with flavor. Ideal for a mid-day snack or post-workout refuel, our Teriyaki Buffalo Jerky will not disappoint.
  • Habanero Buffalo Jerky: Want to spice things up? Our Habanero Buffalo Jerky is perfect for those seeking a kick. The buffalo's natural sweetness perfectly balances the spice from Tabasco and peppers, resulting in a flavor-packed, one-of-a-kind jerky.

No matter which variety you try, we’re confident that your expectations won’t just be met, but exceeded. The only way to know for sure though is to take a chance and place your order today for the best bison jerky online!

Wrapping Up Our Guide to the Best Bison Jerky 

When it comes to buffalo jerky, it's clear that not all products are created equal. The best tasting buffalo jerky combines high-quality ingredients, ethical sourcing, and a careful preparation process to deliver a snack that's not only delicious but also good for you.

And while you came here feeling stressed and uncertain as to what the best buffalo jerky online is, we hope this conversation has left you confident and excited to experience the Mahogany Smoked Meats difference firsthand.

At Mahogany Smoked Meats, we believe we've achieved that balance, providing a selection of buffalo jerky that's head and shoulders above the rest. So why wait? Discover the taste sensation that is our buffalo jerky today. Once you experience our mahogany smoked flavor, we're sure you'll agree - it's simply the best bison jerky online!